He Doesn’t Kcurrently Why is a beautiful single from Fleet Foxes’ self-titled album. On this track, lead singer Robin Pecknold delivers exceptionally intimate, poetic lyrics around feeling puzzled and hopeless once seeing the sad state of a family members member’s life (most most likely his brother). The song is not evidenced to be based in truth, however nonethemuch less Robin’s passionate singing certain provides it feel deeply individual. The song has actually a powerful, catchy melody backed by an excellent folky critical. I witnessed Fleet Foxes live last week and was blvery own amethod by the whole set. Admittedly, prior to that suggest I was a lot more acquainted through Helplessness Blues and Crack-Up than their previous projects. However, the immediate I heard this song I fell in love and I’ve constantly had the self-titled album on repeat since then.

You are watching: Fleet foxes he doesn t know why


I will go with a line by line analysis, in an attempt to analyze the masterful writing and point out what provides this song so beautiful to me.

Pennimuch less and exhausted with your hair grvery own longI was looking at you tbelow and your confront looked wrong

The song starts through Robin seeing his brother for the initially time after a long period acomponent. Robin instantly points out the noticeable transforms in his brother’s appearance. Even though he just uses three descriptors, they are very reliable and also enable the listener to quickly imagine a face, perhaps even a transformation of someone the listener is close to themselves. The usage of the word “penniless” is requirements to be appreciated. With one word, Robin causes the listener to imagine many type of, many type of after-effects of being bad.

Robin ends the second line with “your face looked wrong” which is a really blunt and also devastating statement. After spending a long time along with someone, you develop the principle of a “correct” method they perchild need to look and also act. It is heartbreaking to hear anyone say that that one of their siblings’ deals with looked wrong.

Memory is a fickle siren’s songI didn’t understand

Sirens are mythical creatures recognized to attract seafarers to their fatality through their enchanting singing. This simile is beautiful. It causes us to reflect on the harsh reality that our memories deserve to attract us into making poor decisions. Humans regularly cling too tightly to the past and act dangerously to “go back to the good old days”.

This song is constructed of 4 line sections, as we deserve to tell by the repeating melody and instrumentation. Four lines is not a lot, so we feel that each line should be carefully liked based on prestige. Here Robin just chooses to say that he didn’t understand also. This highlights to the listener the severity of exactly how perplexed he really felt. Robin didn’t, or maybe couldn’t add more information around the situation, so he just chose to emphasize his confusion.

In the gentle light as the morning nearsYou don’t say a single word of the last two years

Robin paints a scene reminiscent of many type of drama movies. We imagine Robin’s brother coming residence prior to dawn and waking Robin up. Even though there is nopoint to perform in the darkness, the two simply overlook each various other. The sunlight gradually rises, which reinpressures the idea of wasted time. Robin’s brvarious other keeps to himself, not wanting to describe what taken place to him and Robin doesn’t ask, not wanting to press also much. When listening, we can only guess exactly how lengthy they’ve been stuck in the silence, making this picture also sadder.

Wbelow you were or as soon as you reached the frontierI didn’t understand

Rather than talking to his brother, Robin proceeds to acquire shed in his thoughts, trying to make sense of what he’s seeing. Of course, he is only able to make wild guesses and is still as confused as prior to. This is presented through his repetition of “I didn’t understand”. As prior to, emphasis is placed on his confusion by cshedding out the four line area through this line.

See your rugged hands and also a silver knifeTwenty dollars in your hand that you organize so tightAll the proof of your vaprovide lifeMy brother, you were gone

Robin starts to point out more observations, having recovered from his initial shock. He starts to observe not just his brother’s appearance, yet likewise what he he is holding. This masterful use of imagery aacquire evokes sadness in us as we are reminded of the disastrous state of Robin’s brvarious other life’s. It additionally brings up many kind of brand-new questions and also answers few. We watch that the brvarious other has actually come to be so negative that he cherishes twenty dollars. We carry out not know what the knife is for or just how his hands have come to be so rugged, yet it is particular that his life has been difficult.

Robin switches it up and does not end this set of 4 lines with “I didn’t understand”. He instead sings “my brvarious other, you were gone”. This is one more heartbreaking lines, comparable to the previous one about his brother’s face looking wrong. Robin feels as though the brvarious other he as soon as kbrand-new and loved doesn’t exist anymore, and also possibly can’t be recovered. Although it is true that Robin still doesn’t fully understand what taken place to his brother, it shows up that he has got enough information to confidently state that his brvarious other is gone.

And you will certainly try to execute what you did beforePull the wool over your eyes for a week or more

The listener learns that this is not new behavior for Robin’s brother. This gives us one more perspective and also locations also even more prestige on the “I didn’t understand” lines. Robin was not only saying that he didn’t understand also what occurred to his brvarious other, he was additionally baffled at how this maybe can have occurred again. These lines are filled through hopelessness, as Robin understands that his brother is stuck in a vicious cycle. He acts recklessly, then preoften tends favor he doesn’t have actually issues and goes earlier to destroying his life. The truth that this has actually become so predictable to Robin renders us feel very sad.

Let your household take you earlier to yourInitial mind

Rather than offering up hope, Robin still tries to convince his brother to let the family members assist him. Even though Robin knows that his brother is stuck in this cycle, he have to still execute all that he have the right to to revive the guy he once kbrand-new. The use of the word “let” is essential below. Robin understands that he can’t force his brvarious other to accept assist. His brother requirements to acknowledge his disastrous habits on his own, otherwise no amount of help deserve to change him.

There’s nopoint I can doThere’s nopoint I deserve to doThere’s nopoint I can sayThere’s nothing I deserve to say, I have the right to say

The last collection of lyrics are a continuation of the idea developed by the previous line. Robin has actually tried to assist his brvarious other and also has currently embraced the truth that there’s nopoint he himself have the right to execute. His brother have to manage his own fate, no amount of pressure from Robin have the right to adjust this.

See more: Did Dylan Sprouse And Jake T. Austin, 11 Former Disney Channel Stars Who Are Ripped Af

After Robin sings the last line, the usual critical continues for a little bit much longer and then the song appears to end up. However, an unintended piano outro comes in. This provides us incredibly confused. We have actually no clue what this outro suggests. Perhaps it is just a means to forget about Robin’s brvarious other, this abrupt adjust in music can just be Robin leaving the subject unreresolved. A happier interpretation could be that the original music has come to be linked to Robin’s confusion and also sadness, and this new instrumental suggests a happier time after his brvarious other actually does go back to his old self. That’s one of the beautiful things around this song, we’re able to decide our own finishing and also take amethod what’s most essential to us.