If a human being is considering a snubbie revolver for hidden carry, a human will most likely come down to 2 choices: S&W J-frame vs Ruger LCR. These space two really popular snubbie revolvers and also arguably the best available.

You are watching: Ruger lcr vs s&w 642

Which is better, though?

That relies on exactly how you define "better." Thing about the J-frame is that the J-frame is actually a totality family of revolvers, v a lot of of options to pick from. The LCR is together well, but to a far lesser degree. In various other words, you get an ext choices as soon as it pertains to the J-frame in terms of structure construction and also accoutrements, however the LCR is hardly a one-trick pony.

Ultimately, it depends on specifically what you"re in search of in a CCW revolver.

Ruger LCR: Optimized because that Carry

Let"s obtain it out of the way: friend don"t gain as much in state of choice with the Ruger LCR (it represents Lightweight lug Revolver) series. You deserve to pick double-action just (the LCR) or a low-profile hammer with the LCRx. The finish can be any color, so lengthy as you choose black. (Though a couple of distributors may have actually some distinct color alternatives available, if the matters.) The frame is a polymer lower and aluminium alloy upper.

You obtain Hogue rubber grips and also a totality lot of surface contours for an easy draw indigenous concealment. Sights are notch rear and also blade front, though you can obtain luminescent front vision inserts and a couple of LCRx models perform come through target behind sights.

You can acquire Crimson trace from the manufacturing facility or order the grips yourself.

You do gain a bit much more choice in terms of caliber, though. You gain the classics, .38 distinct +P and .357 Magnum. There are also .22 LR and also .22 Magnum models, in both the LCR and also LCRx. However, the LCR - though no the LCRx - can additionally be had actually in .327 commonwealth Magnum and also the LCR"s popular 9mm variant. The last requires the use of moon clips, but Ruger sells lock cheap.

Everything you need, nothing girlfriend don"t, yet you can gain a small bit the what girlfriend don"t if girlfriend want.

The LCR has a 1.87-inch barrel throughout the board, save for 2 LCRx models with 3-inch barrels. (One in .38 Special, one in .22 LR.) Unloaded weight is 13.5 ounces at the lightest, 17.2 ounces in ~ the heaviest. Despite the frame contouring, the LCR is contempt bigger than the smaller J-frames, at 4.5 inch tall and also 6.5 inch long, yet slightly narrow at 1.28 inches large at the cylinder.

Granted, fewer selections in appointment over the J-frame series, sure, yet the LCR is draft for function first, i beg your pardon is why a lot of human being regard it together the finest concealed lug revolver ~ above the market.

Ruger LCR Specs:Overall Length: 6.5"Height: 4.5"Barrel Length: 1.87"Width: 1.28"Weight: 13.5oz - 17.2oz

Take advantage of our 30-day check Drive! There"s more Ruger LCR holsters available on our find by Gun page under Ruger on the Revolver tab.

J-Frame Revolvers: liberty of Choice

Thing around the J-frame is there room J-frame revolvers for almost any sensibility. For the many part, you obtain 5 shots the .38 special or .357 Magnum, though there space a pair of 7-shot models in .22 Magnum and also a couple of 8-shot models in .22 LR.

However, everything past that is up to you. What girlfriend can gain depends on what you want and also how lot you"re ready to pay...and there"s a J-frame for almost any budget.

Want wood and also blue steel? The model 36, the standard J-frame, is for you.


Rather have actually a lightweight DAO optimized because that the deepest concealment? try the 642. Want the best of both worlds? The 648 in .38 Special and 649 in .357 Magnum have shrouded hammers, allowing for single or double-action operation yet streamlined for an easy draw indigenous concealment. Lasers space available, as space models v target sights.

And so on. There are more than 3 dozen separation, personal, instance models under the J-frame banner, therefore it"s a buyer"s market. Pick the model you like.

Specs vary by model, however the common barrel length is 1.875 inches v an overall length that 6.3 inches. Some have a 2.125-inch barrel, and a couple of J-frames - many notably the version 60 3" - have a 3-inch barrel, which provides them a tad longer. Broad is 1.3 inches at the cylinder, and most models are roughly 4.2 customs tall, though a few have slightly longer grips for this reason it depends on the precise model girlfriend look at.

Weight additionally varies through model. The lightest is the M&P 340 (the current M&P heat of plastic fantastics room not the an initial to stay the label; the an initial was the design 10) at 13.8 ounces. The most heavy is the model 60 3" in ~ 23.2 ounces. Many of them are 14.4 ounces, so much less than a pound unloaded. Easy to conceal, straightforward to carry, basic to operate - that"s why CCW revolvers space still relevant.

In short, there space so plenty of iterations of the J-frame revolver the it would certainly take every day because that you come read about them. Suffice come say it"s a versatile platform, through offerings come suit practically any pistol buyer"s desires.

S&W J-Frame Specs:Overall Length: 6.3"Height: 4.2"Barrel Length: 1.875"-2.125"Width: 1.3"Weight: 14.4oz

Take advantage of our 30-day check Drive!

J-Frame vs. LCR: The Choice

If you had actually to choose between the J-frame vs. Ruger LCR...it yes, really comes down to i m sorry one friend like. Friend won"t walk wrong either way; it"s prefer choosing in between a Civic and a Camry. Either way you gain a good car that"s going to last.

They"re nearly the very same gun. Both have the right to be obtained for approximately $400 in most gun stores, though you have to anticipate payment a small extra - probably around $50 - because that the Ruger over a base design J-frame. Both room .38 Special and will operation +P, for this reason they room both great defensive pistols, despite .357 Magnum deserve to be had actually if desired.

They"re both about the very same size and weight, though the Ruger is about 1 oz lighter than many J-frames; hardly sufficient to make a major difference. Both deserve to be had actually in DAO or double/single configuration.

However, there are a couple of things that can tilt a human in one direction over another. Ruger installs a friction-reducing camer in the cause group, therefore you get a smoother pull in double-action i beg your pardon some world have bemoaned in S&W revolvers. Expect a 10- to 12-pound pull either way.


That said, there"s a difference in between what friend can uncover on your site and also what you"ll discover in stores. You"re liable to find 2 to 3 J-frames per LCR in the display screen case, therefore you"ll probably find a bit an ext selection in your local gun store among the S&Ws, i m sorry is something come bear in mind.

Try lock both out at a variety if possible, and also see which girlfriend like. The one that feels finest in the hand and also that you have the right to shoot the best is the one you have to get. When you perform go come the range, usage Alien Gear"s complimentary 8" x 11.5" target!

Click the Image listed below to Download


We will repetitively be adding new target options to ours lineup. Inspect out our complete complimentary printable shooting targets web page to see the full choice as they start rolling in.

See more: Welp! 'Bout Time To Hit The Ol Dusty Trail, Time To Hit The Ol' Dusty Trail

Looking for more information on revolver carry? alien Gear"s got you covered:

About The Author

Born in southeastern Washington State, Sam Hoober graduated in 2011 from eastern Washington University. He resides in the good Inland Northwest, through his wife and also child. His differed interests and also hobbies include camping, fishing, hunting, and also spending time in ~ the gun range as regularly as possible.