I to be wondering if this was an original phrase or was it from literature or part speech?


*

It appears it is a watered-down version of Einstein's quote: "So lengthy as there space men, there will be wars." - games have constantly taken motivation from movies and also literature,
Ulysses S. Grant, 18th us President is quoted plenty of times together saying this.

You are watching: War never changes quote origin

I have never promoted war except as way of peace, so seek peace, but prepare because that war. Due to the fact that war... War never ever changes. Battle is like winter and also winter is coming.

Example source

Edit: However, in spite of the plenty of references to this top top the Internet, absence of a proper source way it is probably much more likely the this is a misattribution and the really quote was created by one of the writers on Fallout and read by the narrator, Ron Perlman.

War. War never changes. The Romans waged battle to conference slaves and also wealth. Spain built realm from that is lust for gold and also territory. Hitler shame a quit Germany into an economic superpower. Yet war never ever changes.

Source


re-superstructure
enhance this answer
monitor
edited Dec 7 "15 at 17:18
reply Dec 7 "15 at 16:38
user116295user116295
10
| present 5 much more comments
3
Early instances that the precise sentence

Two sources in the Google publications database contain the phrase "War never changes" as a independent sentence. The earlier of those 2 matches is indigenous "The Day"s work-related of a Soldier," in The World"s Work: 2nd War Manual: The conduct of the War (1914):

"The good Napoleon won his victories due to the fact that the Grand military could outmarch the enemy. That is the exact same to-day. War never changes. just weapons room new. Yet it is not the weapons, but the guys who manage them, that win victories."

This quotation is deadline the head waiter in one unnamed restaurant in one unspecified locale in France, speaking during the first couple of months of what verified to it is in a long and monstrous an initial World War. The is evidently the same quotation that site participant P. O. Cites in a comment beneath Jack Graveney"s prize as showing up in a publication published a year later, Practical Warfare: Chapters on Armies and also Navies in Action (1915).

And from U.S. Congress, House international Affairs Committee, American Neutrality Policy: Hearings ... On present Neutrality Law (1939):

As often as not, our initiative to promote tranquility by preserving neutrality aided the aggressor and also contributed come the calamity the the victim. In the topsy-turvy situation surrounding neutrality, however, war remained the very same grim reality. War never ever changes. It just becomes more bloody and brutal.

Early instances of similar but slightly longer expressions

From "Story of battle Told in field Marshal Haig"s Reports," in the New York Tribune (March 14, 1920):

In this interviews , Foch discusses the immutability of strategic principles. However he states guardedly: "War never alters in that is essence; that only changes in its means." Again: "No. Battle hasn"t changed since men have actually existed. Yet don"t girlfriend realize the it really demands a good deal that art?"

From Walter Karig, Battle Report: The war in Korea, volume 6 (1960) , we have this longer-winded variation of the expression:

But the method of warfare readjust from conflict to problem while the definition of war never changes: in ~ least, no for Americans. The guys who combated from Seoul to the Naktong, who held at Masan, drove v Inchon, blasted a course from Chosin come Hungnam, fought for the exact same national ethics that guided united state at Saratoga, at Algiers, at Manila Bay and San Juan Hill, Château-Thierry, Normandy, Leyte. The isn"t all idealism.

From American Legion magazine, quantities 138–139 (1995) , we have this variant:

One thing around war never ever changes. Those that fight them constantly pray it will certainly end. In Korea, the hope because that peace often took a cruel turn, together Robert McGinn that Huntington, W.Va., recalls.

And native Journal of global Affairs, volume 51 (1997) :

The nature the war never changes; "war," ~ all, "is an action of pressure to compel our opponent to execute our will," as knife von Clausewitz stated over a century and also a fifty percent ago in his publication On War.

Early instances in i beg your pardon "war never ever changes" something else

There are also a variety of matches in Google Books, Elephind, and also Hathi trust search outcomes in i beg your pardon "war never changes" shows up as component of a much longer thought about things that battle cannot change. 2 of these might be of particular interest. From the "Confederate Veterans" Excursion," in the Alexandria Gazette (July 23, 1895):

The attend to of the night was delivered by major Conrad. Throughout his speech significant Conrad said: "War decides nothing. War never ever changes a conviction. War never ever changes any type of man"s honest sentiment. We expropriate the an outcome of the polite war." The principal topic of conversation throughout the evening was the suggest erection that a monument to Gen. Winfield S. Hancock, in new Orleans, through the Confederate Veterans of the joined States.

In a letter date August 6, 1898, from Theodore Roosevelt to his sister Corrine, reprinted in Corinne Roosevelt Robinson, My brothers Theodore Roosevelt (1921):

War never changes that hideous phantasms. The heroism that even modern-day men (and no one the much less of the women that let them go) is the one thing to glory and hope in. We load up tonight. Mine love to all.

From Funk Blentano and also Sorell, quoted in The Thalia (May 5, 1905) a justice decision issued by the Yokosuka prize Court, reprinted in Sakuye Takahashi, International Law applied to the Russo-Japanese War with the decisions of the Japanese compensation Courts (1908):

The civilization of the hostile state have their residential or commercial property in a belligerent state, since they count on the legislation of the last in the defense of residential or commercial property right in simple times. And also as war never ever changes such national law, together state should respect and also protect the enemy’s exclusive property also, as long as it proceeds to offer protection to home rights. Otherwise the an outcome will be that the state violates its very own law.

And from "What the War has Not Changed," in the straight Action (April 22, 1916):

The press and the remainder of our mentors are really careful not to state that there is one point which war never ever changes, i beg your pardon peace never prevents, namely, exploitation. This is a word totally foreign to their vocabulary. Webster, indeed, tells us it is no longer "in use."

Conclusion

Through the years, a number of people have actually voiced the see the that battle in its essence is always the same. The earliest complement in the searches ns ran for the exact sentence "War never ever changes" is attributed to a French waiter in 1914, near the start of the first World War. 6 years later, however, when thinking earlier on the recently concluded very first World War, France"s world-famous ar Marshal Foch states something very similar: "War never transforms in the essence."

I mean that Foch"s comments might have had a bit more impact than the waiter"s. However I favor to imagine the he obtained the idea sooner or later at a coffee shop while eat breakfast and listening to the grumblings of a particularly exasperated server.

On the various other hand, Foch"s connection to the saying "War never changes" doesn"t seem specifically well established in the public mind. Wikiquote, for example, lists 4 quotations from Foch ~ above the topic of war, but Wikiquote qualities the quotation "War never changes" come Scott Campbell, Brian Freyermuth, and Mark O"Green, Fallout, interpreted by Ron Perlman together the narrator (1997).

Similar statements about the immutability the war show up in a Congressional conversation during the uncomfortable days simply prior come the 2nd World War, shortly after the korean War, lengthy after the oriental War, and also in what appears to it is in a general retrospective on battle written in 1997—the exact same year the the quotation appeared in Fallout.

See more: Ted Talk Tuesday: What Makes Us Feel Good About Our Work ? What Makes Us Feel Good About Our Work

Ultimately the most accurate conclusion might be that a lot of people over the years have actually said "War never ever changes," and that nobody of them had to count on any kind of authority beyond their own experience in getting to that formulation. Through the mass-market reach of Fallout, the course, the calculus has changed—because Fallout, unlike field Marshal Foch, appears to have cultural staying strength in today"s neurosoup.org-speaking people (and beyond).