I was wondering if this was an original expression or was it from literary works or some speech?


*

It shows up it is a watered-dvery own version of Einstein's quote: "So long as there are guys, tbelow will be wars." - games have actually constantly taken motivation from movies and also literary works,
Ulysses S. Grant, 18th US President is quoted many times as saying this.

You are watching: War never changes quote origin

I have never before promoted war other than as implies of tranquility, so look for peace, however prepare for battle. Due to the fact that war... War never before changes. War is prefer winter and winter is coming.

Example source

Edit: However before, despite the countless referrals to this on the Web, absence of a correct resource means it is more than likely even more likely that this is a misattribution and also the actual quote was produced by one of the authors on Fallout and check out by the narrator, Ron Perlmale.

War. War never before alters. The Romans waged battle to gather servants and riches. Spain constructed a realm from its lust for gold and also area. Hitler shaped a battered Germany type of into an financial superpower. But war never transforms.

Source


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Dec 7 "15 at 17:18
answered Dec 7 "15 at 16:38
user116295user116295
10
| Show 5 more comments
3
Early instances of the precise sentence

Two resources in the Google Books database contain the expression "War never changes" as a standalone sentence. The earlier of those two matches is from "The Day"s Work of a Soldier," in The World"s Work: Second War Manual: The Conduct of the War (1914):

"The good Napoleon won his victories because the Grand also Military could outmarch the adversary. It is the very same to-day. War never before alters. Only weapons are new. Yet it is not the weapons, but the males who take care of them, who win victories."

This quotation is attributed the head waiter in an uncalled restaurant in an unstated locale in France, speaking during the initially few months of what confirmed to be a long and also monstrous First World War. It is evidently the same quotation that website participant P. O. cites in a comment beneath Jack Graveney"s answer as showing up in a book published a year later, Practical Warfare: Chapters on Armies and Navies in Action (1915).

And from U.S. Congress, Housage Foregime Affairs Committee, Amerideserve to Neutrality Policy: Hearings ... on Present out Neutrality Law (1939):

As often as not, our initiative to promote peace by maintaining neutrality aided the aggressor and added to the calamity of the victim. In the topsy-turvy situation surrounding neutrality, however, battle stayed the very same grim reality. War never before transforms. It just becomes even more bloody and brutal.

Early instances of comparable however slightly longer expressions

From "Story of War Told in Field Marshal Haig"s Reports," in the New York Tribune (March 14, 1920):

In these interviews , Foch discusses the immutcapability of strategic ethics. But he says guardedly: "War never changes in its essence; it just alters in its suggests." Again: "No. War hasn"t readjusted given that guys have actually existed. But do not you realize that it really requirements an excellent deal of art?"

From Wtransform Karig, Battle Report: The War in Korea, volume 6 (1960) , we have this longer-winded version of the expression:

But the means of warfare readjust from conflict to conflict while the definition of war never before changes: at least, not for Americans. The men who combated from Seoul to the Naktong, who hosted at Masan, drove through Inchon, blasted a path from Chosin to Hungnam, battled for the same national principles that guided us at Saratoga, at Algiers, at Manila Bay and also San Juan Hill, Château-Thierry, Normandy, Leyte. It isn"t all idealism.

From Amerihave the right to Legion magazine, quantities 138–139 (1995) , we have this variant:

One point about war never changes. Those that fight them always pray it will certainly finish. In Korea, the hope for tranquility frequently took a cruel turn, as Robert McGinn of Huntington, W.Va., recalls.

And from Journal of International Affairs, volume 51 (1997) :

The nature of battle never before changes; "battle," after all, "is an act of force to compel our enemy to perform our will," as Karl von Clausewitz declared over a century and also a half ago in his book On War.

Early instances in which "battle never before changes" something else

There are likewise a number of matches in Google Books, Elephind, and also Hathi Trust search outcomes in which "war never before changes" shows up as component of a longer believed around things that war cannot adjust. Two of these might be of certain interest. From the "Confedeprice Veterans" Excursion," in the Alexandria Gazette (July 23, 1895):

The resolve of the evening was ceded by Major Conrad. Throughout his speech Major Conrad said: "War decides nopoint. War never before changes a conviction. War never changes any kind of man"s hoswarm sentiment. We accept the result of the civil battle." The major topic of conversation throughout the evening was the proposed erection of a monument to Gen. Winfield S. Hancock, in New Orleans, by the Confederate Veterans of the United States.

In a letter dated August 6, 1898, from Theodore Roosevelt to his sister Corrine, republished in Corinne Roosevelt Robinchild, My Brother Theodore Roosevelt (1921):

War never before changes its hideous phantasms. The heroism of even modern guys (and none the much less of the woguys that let them go) is the one point to glory and also hope in. We fill up tonight. My love to all.

From Funk Blentano and also Sorell, quoted in The Thalia (May 5, 1905) a judicial decision issued by the Yokosuka Prize Court, reprinted in Sakuye Takahashi, International Law Applied to the Russo-Japanese War through the Decisions of the Japanese Prize Courts (1908):

The human being of the hostile state have actually their home in a belligerent state, because they rely on the regulation of the last in the protection of residential or commercial property appropriate in ordinary times. And as battle never changes such national legislation, such state need to respect and also safeguard the enemy’s personal residential property additionally, as lengthy as it proceeds to give defense to building rights. Otherwise the outcome will certainly be that the state violates its very own regulation.

And from "What the War Has Not Changed," in the Direct Action (April 22, 1916):

The push and the remainder of our mentors are incredibly careful not to state that tbelow is one thing which battle never before changes, which peace never avoids, namely, exploitation. This is a word completely international to their vocabulary. Webster, indeed, tells us it is no much longer "in usage."

Conclusion

Thturbulent the years, a number of people have voiced the watch the that war in its significance is constantly the same. The earliest match in the searches I ran for the precise sentence "War never before changes" is attributed to a French waiter in 1914, near the beginning of the First World War. Six years later on, however, while reasoning ago on the newly concluded First World War, France"s world-renowned Field Marshal Foch says something exceptionally similar: "War never before alters in its essence."

I mean that Foch"s comments might have had a bit even more impact than the waiter"s. But I like to imagine that he acquired the idea someday at a café while eating breakfast and listening to the grumblings of a particularly exasperated server.

On the other hand also, Foch"s link to the saying "War never changes" doesn"t seem particularly well established in the public mind. Wikiquote, for instance, lists four quotations from Foch on the topic of war, yet Wikiquote qualities the quotation "War never changes" to Scott Campbell, Brian Freyermuth, and Mark O"Green, Fallout, understood by Ron Perlman as the narrator (1997).

Comparable statements around the immutcapability of war appear in a Congressional discussion throughout the uneasy days simply prior to the Second World War, quickly after the Oriental War, lengthy after the Oriental War, and in what shows up to be a basic retrospective on battle created in 1997—the very same year that the quotation appeared in Fallout.

See more: Ted Talk Tuesday: What Makes Us Feel Good About Our Work ? What Makes Us Feel Good About Our Work

Ultimately the most precise conclusion may be that a lot of people over the years have sassist "War never transforms," and also that none of them had actually to rely on any type of authority past their very own experience in getting to that formulation. With the mass-sector reach of Fallout, of course, the calculus has actually changed—because Fallout, unfavor Field Marshal Foch, seems to have cultural continuing to be power in today"s neurosoup.org-speaking people (and beyond).