Identify the problems present and also the compromises reached in drafting the ConstitutionSummarize the core functions of the framework of U.S. Government under the Constitution

In 1786, Virginia and Maryland invite delegates indigenous the various other eleven states to meet in Annapolis, Maryland, for the objective of amendment the Articles that Confederation. However, only five states sent representatives. Because all thirteen states had to agree to any modification of the Articles, the convention in Annapolis might not attain its goal. Two of the delegates, Alexander Hamilton and also James Madison, requested that all says send delegates to a convention in Philadelphia the complying with year to attempt when again to review the short articles of Confederation. Every the states other than Rhode Island made decision delegates come send come the meeting, a complete of seventy men in all, however many did no attend. Amongst those no in attendance were john Adams and Thomas Jefferson, both of whom were abroad representing the country as diplomats. Since the shortcomings the the short articles of Confederation proved impossible to overcome, the convention that met in Philadelphia in 1787 chose to produce an entirely brand-new government.

You are watching: Why were southern states concerned about congress controlling foreign trade

Points the Contention

Fifty-five delegates arrived in Philadelphia in may 1787 because that the meeting that became known together the Constitutional Convention. Numerous wanted to strengthen the duty and authority of the national government but feared producing a main government that was as well powerful. Castle wished to preserve state autonomy, although no to a level that prevent the says from working together collectively or make them entirely independent that the will of the national government. When seeking to defend the legal rights of individuals from government abuse, they however wished to develop a society in which involves for law and also order did not give means in the face of requirements for separation, personal, instance liberty. Castle wished to give political civil liberties to all totally free men but likewise feared lot rule, which countless felt would have actually been the result of Shays’ Rebellion had it succeeded.

Delegates from little states go not want their interests moved aside through delegations from an ext populous states choose Virginia. And everyone was concerned about slavery. Representatives from southern claims worried that delegates from states where it had actually been or was being abolished might shot to outlaw the institution. Those who favored a nation totally free of the influence of enslavement feared the southerners could attempt to make it a permanent part of American society. The only decision that all can agree on was the choice of George Washington, the previous commander of the continent Army and hero the the American Revolution, together the president of the convention.

The question of Representation: little States vs. Large States

One that the first differences among the delegates to come to be clear was in between those from huge states, such as brand-new York and Virginia, and those who represented little states, favor Delaware. When stating the structure of the government under the new constitution, the delegates native Virginia dubbed for a bicameral legislature consists of 2 houses. The number of a state’s representatives in each house was come be based upon the state’s population. In each state, representatives in the lower residence would be elected by renowned vote. These representatives would certainly then select their state’s to represent in the upper residence from amongst candidates suggest by the state’s legislature. Once a representative’s hatchet in the legislature had ended, the representative could not be reelected until an unspecified amount of time had actually passed.

Delegates from tiny states objected come this Virginia Plan. An additional proposal, the New Jersey Plan, dubbed for a unicameral legislature through one house, in which every state would have one vote. Thus, smaller states would have the very same power in the nationwide legislature as bigger states. However, the larger states argued that due to the fact that they had more residents, they need to be allotted an ext legislators to stand for their interests.


This infographic reflects the approaches proposed because that counting slave populations and also the resulting Three-Fifths Compromise.

Indeed, the Constitution contained two protections for slavery. Write-up I postponed the abolition that the international slave trade until 1808, and in the interim, those in slaveholding claims were allowed to income as many slaves as they wished.<2>

Furthermore, the Constitution put no constraints on the domestic slave trade, so citizens of one state could still market enslaved people to other states. Short article IV the the Constitution—which, among other things, compelled states to return fugitives to the states where they had actually been charged with crimes—also prevented slaves from obtaining their liberty by escaping to states where slavery had actually been abolished. Clause 3 of short article IV (known as the fugitive servant clause) enabled slave owner to reclaim their person property in the says where slaves had fled.<3>

Separation the Powers and also Checks and also Balances

Although disputes over slavery and representation in congress occupied many at the convention, the chief issue was the an obstacle of enhancing the government of the national federal government while ensuring that it walk not come to be too powerful. The framers solved this trouble through a separation of powers, splitting the national government into three different branches and also assigning different responsibilities to each one. They also created a mechanism of checks and balances by giving each of 3 branches of government the strength to restrict the actions of the others, therefore requiring them to work-related together.


Reserve powers allow the claims to pass intrastate legislation, such as laws on commerce, drug use, and marriage (a). However, occasionally judicial rulings in ~ the commonwealth level might supersede such legislation, as happened in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), the current Supreme Court case regarding marriage equality (b). (credit a: alteration of job-related by Damian Gadal; credit b: alteration of work-related by Ludovic Bertron)

Although the states kept a substantial degree the sovereignty, the supremacy clause in write-up VI of the constitution proclaimed that the Constitution, regulations passed by Congress, and also treaties make by the federal federal government were “the supreme law of the Land.” In the occasion of a conflict between the states and the nationwide government, the national federal government would triumph. Furthermore, although the federal government was come be limited to those strength enumerated in the Constitution, write-up I detailed for the expansion of Congressional strength if needed. The “necessary and proper” i of short article I offers that Congress might “make all regulations which shall it is in necessary and also proper because that carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all various other Powers vested by this structure in the government of the unified States, or in any kind of Department or Officer thereof.”

The Constitution additionally gave the commonwealth government control over every “Territory or other Property belonging to the united States.” This would certainly prove problematic when, as the united States increased westward and populace growth led to rise in the power of the north states in Congress, the federal government sought come restrict the development of slavery right into newly acquired territories.

A growing number of institutes and study centers emphasis on the Constitution and the establishing of the republic. Instances such as the Institute for the American constitution Heritage and also the invoice of civil liberties Institute have informative public websites with documents and videos. One more example is the nationwide Constitution facility that additionally holds programs associated to facets of the enduring U.S. Constitution.

Realizing that flaws in the short articles of Confederation might harm the brand-new country and recognizing the the write-ups could not conveniently be amendment as initially intended, delegates native the claims who met in Philadelphia from may through September 1787 collection about drafting a new governing document. The United says that emerged from the constitution Convention in September was not a confederation, but it was a republic whose national government had been strengthened greatly. Congress had actually been transformed into a bicameral legislative branch with additional powers, and also a nationwide judicial system had actually been created. Many importantly, a federal system had been developed with the power to administrate the new country.

To accomplish the comes to of those that feared an too many strong central government, the framers the the Constitution produced a system with separation the powers and checks and balances. Although such steps satisfied many, pertains to still lingered the the federal government remained too powerful.

See more: Ja I Am Made Of Dur Butter, Let'S Play Bioforce Ape 01:

Separation that powers describes the process of separating government into various branches and also giving different responsibilities and also powers to every branch. In this way, the different branches should work together to administer the nation. Because that example, follow to the Constitution, Congress has actually the power to draft legislation. However, the president have to sign a piece of proposed legislation prior to it becomes a law. Thus, the president and also Congress must work together to do the nation’s laws.

bicameral legislature a legislature with two houses, such as the U.S. Congress

checks and balances a system that allows one branch of government to limit the practice of strength by another branch; calls for the different parts of federal government to work together

enumerated powers the powers given clearly to the federal government by the structure (Article I, ar 8); power to control interstate and also foreign commerce, raise and also support armies, declare war, coin money, and also conduct foreign affairs

federal system a type of government in which strength is divided between state governments and also a national government

Great Compromise a compromise in between the Virginia Plan and the brand-new Jersey setup that created a two-house Congress; depiction based on populace in the house of Representatives and equal representation of says in the Senate

New Jersey Plan a setup that dubbed for a one-house national legislature; every state would obtain one vote

reserved powers any kind of powers no prohibited by the structure or delegated come the nationwide government; powers scheduled to the states and denied to the federal government

separation that powers the share of powers amongst three different branches that government

supremacy clause the statement in article VI the the Constitution that federal legislation is premium to regulations passed through state legislatures

Three-Fifths Compromise a compromise between northern and southern claims that dubbed for counting of all a state’s totally free population and 60 percent of its slave population for both federal taxation and representation in Congress

unicameral legislature a legislative branch with only one house, like the Confederation conference or the legislature proposed by the new Jersey Plan

veto the strength of the chairman to disapprove a legislation proposed through Congress

Virginia Plan a setup for a two-house legislature; representatives would be chosen to the lower house based on each state’s population; representatives for the upper home would be preferred by the reduced house